Events, decisions, and reports at City Council this week
Vancouver City Council met this week to hear and discuss a variety of topics during Council and Public Hearing meetings.
Tuesday January 21, 2020
Council began with a proclamation recognizing Lunar New Year.
Staff from BC Assessment then presented the 2020 Assessment Roll PDF file (2 MB) to Council and responded to questions.
Council considered Unfinished Business - City of Vancouver Responsible Divestment from Fossil Fuels PDF file (57 KB). Council then approved City of Vancouver Responsible Divestment from Fossil Fuels PDF file (58 KB) after debate and questions, and several amendments.
Council also approved several Reports and Referral Reports
- 2020 Council Meetings Schedule Revision PDF file (48 KB)
- Heritage Revitalization Agreement Amendment - 959 East 35th Avenue PDF file (921 KB)
- 2020 Cultural Grants (First Quarter Instalments, Advance Grants, Arts Capacity) PDF file (127 KB)
- Application for Payment-in-Lieu at 325 Carrall Street PDF file (62 KB)
- CD-1 Rezoning: 3235-3261 Clive Avenue PDF file (3 MB)
- Simplified and Expanded Zoning and Development Regulations for Passive House Projects PDF file (111 KB)
- CD-1 Rezoning: 4338-4362 Cambie Street PDF file (3 MB)
- CD-1 Text Amendment: 1500 West Georgia Street PDF file (192 KB)
Council approved several by-laws.
Several motions from Councillors were then discussed:
- Designating January 29th as Day of Remembrance and Action on Islamophobia PDF file (60 KB) was approved
- Preserving Single Room Occupancy Stock Surrounding New St. Paul’s Hospital Site PDF file (100 KB) was approved
- Aligning the Healthy City Strategy with the UN Sustainable Development Goals PDF file (45 KB) was approved
“I was really happy that my motion on designating Jan. 29th as a day of remembrance and action against Islamophobia passed unanimously,” said Councillor Jean Swanson. “My motion for a staff report on how to prevent the loss of low income Single Room Occupancy Hotels because of gentrification created by the new St. Pauls hospital also passed. And, to top it off, Council passed a motion calling for divestment of city funds from fossil fuels.”
The following two motions were referred to the Standing Committee on City Finance and Services meeting on January 22nd to hear from speakers:
- Making it Easier for the Public to Speak at Council Meetings PDF file (59 KB)
- Election Finance: Transparent Funding in Local Politics PDF file (48 KB)
On Tuesday evening, a Public Hearing was held.
- MISCELLANEOUS AMENDMENT: Zoning and Development By-law and Sign Fee By-law PDF file (17 KB) was approved.
- TEXT AMENDMENT: 188 East 6th Avenue (formerly 2221-2223 Main Street) PDF file (24 KB) was approved.
- REZONING: 1956-1990 Stainsbury Avenue PDF file (22 KB) was approved after hearing from seven speakers.
- REZONING: 3600 East Hastings Street PDF file (23 KB) was referred for discussion and decision to the Public Hearing on January 28, 2020 at 3pm after Council heard from 16 speakers
Wednesday, January 22, 2020
A Standing Committee on City Finance and Services was held on Wednesday.
The City’s Chief of Internal Audit presented on the Internal Audit Division PDF file (1.6 MB) to Council.
The Council also approved several Agenda Items:
- Community Amenity Contribution (CAC) Policy Update PDF file (8 MB) was approved with amendments after hearing from five speakers.
Referred motions from November 27, 2019 meeting were discussed:
- Council approved Employment Lands & Economy Review – Update on Phase 1 and Next Steps PDF file (218 KB) with one amendment.
Council referred debate and decision for item 5 PDF file (90 KB) and item 6 PDF file (125 KB) to the reconvening Council portion of the Standing Committee meeting, immediately following the Public Hearing on Tuesday, January 28, 2020.
Thursday, January 23, 2020
On Thursday evening, a Public Hearing was held.
- TEXT AMENDMENT: 505 Smithe Street PDF file (20 KB) was approved
- REZONING: 916-926 West 32nd Avenue PDF file (20 KB) was approved
- REZONING: 514 West 61st Avenue PDF file (20 KB) was approved
- REZONING: 2209-2249 East Broadway PDF file (21 KB) was approved
- REZONING: 8420 Kerr Street and 3104-3130 Southeast Marine Drive PDF file (26 KB) was approved
The Public Hearing will reconvene on Thursday, January 30, 2020, beginning at 3 pm, to receive closing comments from the staff and applicant, debate and decision on Item 6 - TEXT AMENDMENT: 1980 Foley Street PDF file (21 KB), followed by Item 7 - REZONING: 878-898 West Broadway PDF file (22 KB).
The next Council meeting is scheduled for February 11, 2020.
Please see amended motions below. These are provided for your understanding and the published minutes will be the official record of the meeting.
- The 2016 Union of BC Municipalities (UBCM) report, Primer on Fossil Fuel Divestment and the Municipal Pension Plan (MPP), noted that “the MPP imperative is to provide income security for retired members” and “Divestment may compromise our investment strategy, increase risks and costs, and negatively affect our clients’ investment returns”;
- The B.C. Municipal Pension Plan is managed by British Columbia Investment Management Corporation (“BCI”), an asset manager that encourages responsible investing principles and is one of the founding members to the United Nations Principles for Responsible Investment in 2006. BCI has noted that their responsible investment approach is that being an investor and influencing change is more effective than to divest. Other investment firms such as Caisse Quebec are moving more aggressively to manage the impact and risks of fossil fuels by reducing their holdings and encouraging investment in renewable energy;
- In May 2016, Council adopted a Responsible Investment Screening Process for the City’s investment portfolio. The recommended screening process for investing in Canadian banks and credit unions uses a typical structure of environmental, social, and governance (“ESG”) factors within a responsible investing perspective;
- In February 2018, Council directed staff to report back on “what the implications would be of the City of Vancouver moving its Municipal Finance Authority (“MFA”) Investments into a fossil-free Socially Responsible Investment (“SRI”) fund if such a fund is established by the MFA”. Staff reported in March 2018, that the City does not invest in any MFA pooled investment funds, and therefore would not have MFA funds to move into a fossil-free SRI fund. Since then, as the City has been a leader in the responsible investment area, staff have engaged with MFA to support the creation of MFA pooled investment funds that align with a fossil free approach and MFA has introduced two new Pooled High Interest Savings Accounts that meet the short term investment needs of fossil fuel free investors and will also be introducing an MFA Mortgage Fund which has a small, greatly reduced exposure to fossil fuel companies. In addition, MFA has been engaging with asset managers with the view of creating a new short-term bond fund with a fossil fuel exclusion screen that would exclude securities of companies directly involved in the extraction, processing and transportation of coal, oil, or natural gas;
- In 2017, the Chief Financial Officer of the City signed a letter from the “Accounting for Sustainability (A4S)” initiative of Chief Financial Officers, supporting climate-related financial disclosure. The letter specifically commits the City to “affirm our commitment to support the voluntary recommendations” of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”). In 2018, the City was the first Canadian municipality to include climate-related financial disclosures in its annual financial report. The City’s disclosure aligns or partially aligns with TCFD recommendations, and will continue to improve over time as the City responds to climate change, and as the field of climate-risk disclosure evolves. The City is currently working with the City of Toronto, the City of Montreal, and CPA (Chartered Professional Accountants) Canada to develop and align standards for other municipalities to follow TCFD disclosures in their financial reports;
- In June 2018, the City developed its Green Bond Framework and engaged Sustainalytics, a global leading provider of Socially Responsible strategies, to provide a second-party opinion on the City’s alignment with the four core components of the Green Bond Principles Framework. In October 2018, the City issued its inaugural Green Bond of $85 million for capital projects that include investments in renewable energy, energy efficiency, green buildings and clean transportation;
- Since then, with scientific validation of accelerating global warming and the need to leave fossil fuel reserves in the ground, there has been increasing awareness of the investment risk related to fossil fuel “stranded assets”. The October 2018 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report calling for rapid reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, with a window of little more than a decade to avert catastrophic impacts of climate change, has shifted the rationale for divesting from an ethical or moral consideration to a financial and fiduciary argument: “Divestment, once strictly a moral call to action, is now also seen as the only prudent financial response to climate risk” 350.org;
- In January 2019, Council voted unanimously to recognize a global climate emergency and local climate crisis;
- In June 2019, noting a B.C. government report that projects the City of Vancouver will have to spend $1 billion this century to mitigate rising sea levels, Council approved a motion to write to “the 20 fossil fuel companies with the highest percentage of greenhouse gas emissions to ask that they be accountable for their share of climate emergency costs;
- In October 2019, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, told delegates at a climate change summit in Copenhagen that big investors such as insurers and pension funds should cut their investments and focus on renewable energy sources instead;
- Divestment is now a rapidly growing worldwide movement. The total sum of global funds committed to fossil fuel divestment was $52 billion in 2014, $8 trillion in 2018 and $11 trillion in 2019. In 2019, more than 1,110 funds (including wealth funds, banks, cities, pension funds and insurance firms) have made divestment commitments, including Norway’s $1 trillion sovereign wealth fund, the world’s largest. Caisse Quebec – Quebec’s equivalent to B.C.’s pension fund manager – has more than $285-billion in assets under management and says it believes it is the first North American institutional investor to set a carbon target covering all of its asset classes: “There are going to be stranded assets associated with climate change. We don’t want to get caught in those stranded assets … We’re looking for opportunities because we think it’s good risk management to, over time, exit those.” Michael Sabia, President and CEO of Caisse Quebec;
- The cities-led responsible investment movement is growing. More and more cities around the world, including New York City, Paris, London, Oslo, Sydney, Melbourne, Aukland, San Francisco and Seattle, are manifesting their climate leadership through making a divestment commitment. To support cities in exploring and developing their divestment and sustainable investment strategies, the global Cities Climate Leadership Group C40, in close partnership with London and New York City, launched the Divest/Invest Forum in September 2018. The Forum is open to any city that seeks learn more about divestment, sustainable investment, and other climate-responsive financial strategies; no actions or commitments are required as a prerequisite to joining.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT City Council direct staff to review and report back, if possible in 2020, on the following items:
A. A plan that includes defining divestment, options and timelines for how the City could fully divest from fossil fuels, building on divestment measures taken to date as well as leading practices related to fossil fuel free investment portfolios.
B. Opportunities to continue to engage the Municipal Finance Authority to create a fossil fuel free fund that would enable other B.C. municipalities to invest in such a fund.
C. Bringing a motion to Council for the 2020 meetings of the Lower Mainland Local Government Association and the Union of B.C. Municipalities (UBCM) to re-examine the 2016 UBCM Primer on Fossil Fuel Divestment and the Municipal Pension Plan report, in light of globally changing investment and divestment strategies.
D. Evaluating the benefit and costs of the City and Vancouver Economic Commission participating on the C40 Invest/Divest forum, including attending its March 2020 workshop.
E. The Mayor, on behalf of Council and the City of Vancouver write to the B.C. Municipal Pension Plan requesting a risk assessment of the plan’s investments based on carbon exposure, asking the Plan to advise the City on what steps are being taken to measure and mitigate these risks, and urging the Plan to consider the long-term impact of global climate emergency and local climate crisis due to investments in fossil fuel assets and to redeploy funds into green and renewable assets that are necessary for a sustainable future.
F. The Mayor, on behalf of Council and the City of Vancouver, send a letter to the Province of BC to encourage them to follow the examples of Canadian municipalities in developing a model for crown corporations and provincial agencies to include financial statement disclosures aligned with the TCFD (Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures).
G. The Mayor, on behalf of the City of Vancouver, a C40 City, sign the Global Green New Deal pledge which was signed by the other C40 mayors at their meeting in Copenhagen in October of 2019. That pledge includes an “urgent, fundamental and irreversible transfer of global resources away from fossil fuels and into action that averts the climate emergency.”
A. THAT Council repeal and replace the “Community Amenity Contributions through Rezonings Policy” found in Appendix A of the report dated January 8, 2020, entitled “Community Amenity Contribution (CAC) Policy Update”, with the “Community Amenity Contributions Policy for Rezonings” generally as contained in Appendix B of the above-noted report.
B. THAT Council adopt a CAC Target of $3.00 per sq.ft. applicable to 100% institutional rezoning applications of hospitals, care facilities and post-secondary schools, with the CAC Target taking effect upon Council approval.
C. THAT Council instruct staff to notify landowners and in-stream rezoning applications of the City’s intent to increase CAC Targets in the Little Mountain Adjacent and Southeast False Creek M-2 zoned areas to $47.00 and $67.00 per sq.ft. respectively, and report back on an implementation plan in July 2020.
D. THAT Council direct staff to monitor and report back to Council on the need to index cash CACs between Council approval in-principle of a rezoning application and rezoning enactment by Council and/or impose a required time limit to enact a new zoning, whereby if the time limit lapses, the approval in-principle of the rezoning application may expire.
E. THAT Council direct staff to report back on a city-wide CAC allocation strategy following public engagement on the Vancouver Plan and the completion of the City’s 10-year Capital Strategic Outlook.
F. THAT Council direct staff to report back to Council on the potential for allocation of Community Amenity Contributions to neighbourhood houses, arts venues and other non-profit venues that support growth and ongoing community services delivery in Vancouver through contributions to external endowment funds that support such organizations.
FURTHER THAT the report back review key considerations such as but not limited to legal considerations and requirements for potential external endowment fund recipients.
THAT Council receive this project update report and initial list of economic and employment lands challenges and opportunities and direct staff to continue engagement with Vancouver Economic Commission (VEC), stakeholders, the public, and others, including integration into the Vancouver Plan engagement processes, to identify high level policy directions and report back to Council in mid-2020 in parallel with the Vancouver Plan report back on challenges and principles.